Our Top 4 Reader-Favorite American Recipes From This Month

These American recipes are the kind you’ll want to share—and make again right away. From BBQ chicken sliders to cozy toast, every dish is tried, tested, and reader-approved for when nothing else sounds good.

Updated on Fri, 08 May 2026
Tender shredded BBQ chicken nestled in slider buns, paired with golden fries for crunch.  Save
Tender shredded BBQ chicken nestled in slider buns, paired with golden fries for crunch. | sweetbatata.com
01 of 4

BBQ Chicken Sliders with Crispy Fries

Tender shredded BBQ chicken nestled in slider buns, paired with golden fries for crunch.
Tender shredded BBQ chicken nestled in slider buns, paired with golden fries for crunch. | sweetbatata.com

Sweet, smoky BBQ chicken sliders piled with cheddar and tangy coleslaw, served alongside oven-baked crispy fries—classic American comfort on a tray.

View Recipe Save
02 of 4

Broccoli-Stuffed Manicotti

Broccoli-Stuffed Manicotti
sweetbatata.com

I didn’t expect my family to love a veggie pasta so much, but these cheesy broccoli manicotti were a huge hit. Super creamy and filling! —Janet L.

View Recipe Save
03 of 4

Chicken à la King on Buttered Toast

Chicken à la King on Buttered Toast
sweetbatata.com

Creamy chicken and mushrooms spooned over thick, golden toast—this retro favorite brings major comfort (and plenty of cozy flavor) to the table.

View Recipe Save
04 of 4

Buffalo Chicken Smash Tacos

Golden, smashed Buffalo Chicken Smash Burger Tacos, ready to be devoured with fresh, colorful ranch slaw.
Golden, smashed Buffalo Chicken Smash Burger Tacos, ready to be devoured with fresh, colorful ranch slaw. | sweetbatata.com

The spicy, crispy chicken with cool ranch slaw makes the perfect taco! My kids ask for these every week. —MikeCooks

View Recipe Save